Skip to main content

Sandwiches

When you want a lunch worth stopping for, a sandwich shop inside a butcher shop is hard to beat. Every sandwich at The Flying Butcher starts with the same case we sell from: our own slow-roasted rare roast beef, house smoked turkey breast, hand-pressed burgers, and the steak and cheese that regulars drive across town for. Custom-made sandwiches are always available — tell us what you're craving and we'll build it.

The three most-ordered sandwiches at our counter, year after year: the Cheese Steak, the Steak Tip, and the Smoked Turkey BLT. Start with one of those and you'll understand why the line forms at lunch.

Hot Sandwiches

Warm, hearty, and made when you order. Our hot sandwiches run from the classic steak and cheese to house smoked barbecue.

  • Cheese Steak — shaved steak and American cheese on a garlic butter grilled sub roll. The most-ordered sandwich in the shop.
  • Steak Tip — our famous Steakhouse steak tips with American cheese on a garlic butter grilled sub roll
  • Pulled Pork Po' Boy — house smoked pulled pork with BBQ sauce, coleslaw, and pickles on a grilled onion roll
  • Corned Beef Reuben — tender corned beef with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Thousand Island sauce on thick marble rye
  • Ham and Swiss Melt — grilled country ham, melted Swiss, and sliced pickles on a warm brioche bun with sweet and spicy mustard
  • TFB Cuban — ham, pulled pork, and melted Swiss with pickles and deli mustard on a pressed ciabatta roll
  • Meatball Fra Diavolo — house-made Italian meatballs, spicy marinara, crispy fried jalapeños, and provolone on a garlic butter grilled sub roll
  • Italian Sausage Sub — our house-made hot and sweet Italian sausage with grilled peppers and onions on a garlic butter grilled sub roll
  • Chicken Sandwich — breaded chicken cutlet, hot honey, lettuce, tomato, and pickles on a grilled brioche roll
  • BBQ Pulled Chicken — smoked BBQ pulled chicken with pickled red onion, Muenster cheese, and chipotle aioli on a grilled sub roll
  • The Veggie — balsamic grilled squash, bell peppers, lettuce, and tomato with basil aioli on a toasted ciabatta roll

Cold Sandwiches & Wraps

Made with Boar's Head meats and cheeses, our own roasted and smoked meats, and the freshest produce in the store.

  • Smoked Turkey BLT — our house smoked turkey breast with smoked gouda, thick-cut bacon, mixed greens, tomatoes, and basil pesto aioli on a ciabatta roll
  • Italian — Boar's Head Genoa salami, capicola, mortadella, and piccante provolone with mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, aged balsamic, and extra virgin olive oil on a ciabatta roll
  • TFB Roast Beef — our own slow-cooked roast beef with cheddar, mixed greens, tomatoes, red onion, and horseradish sauce on a fresh onion roll
  • Tuna Salad Wrap — with lettuce, tomato, and red onion on your choice of wrap
  • Chicken Salad Wrap — our house chicken salad with mixed greens and tomato on your choice of wrap
  • Chicken Caesar Wrap — romaine tossed with chicken, parmesan, and Caesar dressing

Burgers

Our burgers are hand-pressed from the same beef we grind for the case — 10 and 12 ounce patties, cooked to order on a brioche roll.

  • Cheeseburger — a 10 oz. hand-pressed burger with melted cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, and bomb sauce
  • Belly Buster Burger — a 10 oz. burger topped with BBQ pulled pork, slab bacon, and melted cheese
  • Blue Cheese Peppercorn Burger — a 12 oz. burger loaded with blue cheese, crusted in peppercorns, and served with lettuce, tomato, and onion

Call Ahead

Skip the wait: call (603) 598-6328 and your order will be ready when you arrive. Our team makes every sandwich to order, so if you want it built differently — different bread, extra meat, no aioli — just say so. We're in the Lowe's plaza on Route 101A in Amherst, minutes from Merrimack, Nashua, and Milford.